Resolving Realities Friday, January 12, 2007 at 3:33 pm
Welcome to this sliver of my world on the web.
I should introduce myself. I’m David, and for now that’s all I’m going to say. No places, no specifics, at least not for now: I’m too much in the closet in real life for all of that. But I’ve recently – within the past several weeks – made the tentative switch over to a “Side A” gay Christian, after years and years of being “Side X”. What does that mean, you ask? Well, there are Christians, like me, who happen to be same-sex attracted. There are three sides to dealing this:
1) Side A: You can be gay and Christian. God blesses committed, monogamous same-sex relationships
2) Side B: You can be gay and Christian. But it is God’s desire for you to remain celibate
3) Side X: You cannot self-identify as gay and be Christian. You must change and be transformed by God to being straight
Armed with terminology which will come in useful in future posts, I will now give you a history of what has brought me to where I am today, setting up this semi-anonymous blog.
I grew up in the setting of an evangelical church. I hesitate to say I “grew up Christian” because I’m not entirely sure what that’s supposed to mean. I can’t tell you the date I came to understand the gospel. But I do know that as time went on I gradually came to understand that I had to rely on God’s grace through Jesus Christ, who lived, died, and resurrected to reconcile me to himself, rather than on my own goodness. That part about my own goodness not being sufficient was shocking, and it still causes difficulties: grace not works; mercy not legalism. But at the heart of all this is Christ. He is beautiful beyond all words: I look at the cross – at “the Passion” – and I see the most compelling expression of love in the most perfect person the world has ever seen. What response is there but worship?
I knew I was attracted to other guys in middle school, and it freaked me out. I spent most of those pubescent and post-pubescent years in the belief that my homosexuality was the struggle I had to face. It was the sin in my life I had to rid myself of so that I could serve God. And no one could ever know, because I was scared of being rejected and losing any fellowship, not realizing that hiding myself away was already destroying much opportunity for fellowship. Most of the church teaches that homosexuality is a sin, and I believed this, without looking into it. And I knew throughout that I loved and wanted to serve God, and spent so many tearful nights in prayer begging him to change me. There are acts I’m not proud of in my past, but I never hooked up with anyone (I’ve never even kissed a guy!) – but I always reasoned that if the act was a sin, so too the desire must be sinful. I tried all sorts of explanations for it, ranging from it being a phase to being a result of non-existent ‘idolatry’ on my behalf to adopting the rather damaging ex-gay pseudo-psychology, but I was still too closeted to attend a meeting. I tried to change, I really did. And I believed that God would change me, because he’s sovereign, and he loves me.
But one can only spend so long in such a place. I developed a profound sense of self-loathing, and barred myself from leadership positions: after all, how could a sinner as great as myself minister to others? This was a damaging and selfish place for me to be, and only led to depression, deep cynicism, and sin.
Fast forward to a few months ago, when my worldview crashed down around me. I attempted to date a girl over the summer – a rather nice-looking one, as far as girls go. She also was and is incredibly godly. We were getting to know each other and I enjoyed the friendship we shared. I also had been doing extremely well with my struggle against lust, and assumed that this must mean that I was “cured.” So telling her that I had “struggled with homosexuality” – but hiding that I might possibly still be gay – I asked her out. A godly girl, what more could I ask for?
It failed. She was clearly interested in me, but I couldn’t bring myself to be any more than a friend to her. I was hoping an attraction would develop, but none did. And God kept convicting me that if I wasn’t really attracted to her, I was depriving her of a fuller relationship she could have. I want her to have a man who can drink in her form with his eyes and have something in his breast say, “I am fulfilled.” I can never give her that.
My worldview died. I had no way to handle that, and had to come back to the realization that I was in fact gay. It’s not about lust, or rebellion, or a lifestyle. And so I decided to look into the actual biblical perspective on my sexuality, and read about both sides. That was about three months ago. After a lot of intensive study and prayer, I have to say that I lean fairly substantially toward saying that it would not be a sin for me to enter into a lifelong monogamous relationship with another man – provided that it is Christ-centered (Side A). But I have only been there for five or so weeks. I’m still working all this out, and trying to normalize what I considered for most of my life to be my principal struggle. And I suppose it’s still possible that I may go ’round full circle and decide that God calls all gay Christians to celibacy (Side B). It has not been long, after all, since I’ve held the Side X view. But in all things I have to exalt my savior, Jesus Christ. Though I may come across other apparent dichotomies, and I almost certainly will, this blog is a place for me as I’m working out resolving these two realities: the reality of a God whom I love, and the reality of my attractions.



Wow David.
Its Jennifer R. Pat’s wife. We had coffee together a few times last summer.
I don’t know what to say. I just discovered your blog as it is linked to your profile at the discussion board for our faith community.
I am blown away at your authenticity and your honesty. I understand greatly what it is to struggle with owning certain sexual desires and yet I know I don’t go through nearly the kind of emotional wrangling that you must have begun to walk through this year.
I am fortunate because any “deviant” sexual desires I have are pretty well housed in the fact that I am straight and in a committed marriage so I get that “get out of jail free” card in a sense.
I don’t think it would be authentic to say “I know what you are going through” because how could a straight woman in her thirties have a clue what it must really be like to experience your confusion and pain.
But, that said, so much of what you write touches my soul in a deep and profound way. There is no closet for me to come out of because my sexual desires are not the focus of anyone’s judgement and I don’t have to face owning things publicly the way you do at your stage in life’s journey.
However, I understand this very much: “My worldview died. I had no way to handle that, and had to come back to the realization that I was in fact gay. It’s not about lust, or rebellion, or a lifestyle. And so I decided to look into the actual biblical perspective on my sexuality, and read about both sides.”
i have had my worldview die, many times over in fact and each time more painful than the first. But when it hit in the area of sexuality it was something from which I never thought I could recover. I literally felt like I was crawling through the rubble of a war zone and it left me in a place where I became a church leaver in my heart (I was in professional ministry at the time which put a nice ironic twist on that issue) and almost an atheist. I could not reconcile what I knew my heart was saying with what I had been trained to believe. And what my heart was saying, many Sunday School teachers would say was at least the beginning if not the end of a slippery slope that would land me in the pitt of hell.
I would love to say I am completely over it but that would be false. I will say that I personally glean so much hope from what I have seen in your blog so far. Because I see that someone else is at least making an effort to enter that struggle of reconstructing what has been deconstructed with honesty and authenticity.
I was lucky because I was found. But I know so many others, many of them gay, who were not so lucky and honestly who just gave up not just on church but even more importantly on God. They simply couldn’t reconcile who they knew themselves to be with what they perceived they were being forced to claim to be or not be.
I believe that sexuality is one major reason why so many leave faith all together.
What is so very encouraging to me in what I have glanced at here, is the fact that you are not just facing this stuff but you are bringing it to God and wrestling with it there. It would be so much easier to run.
It seems to me that as you are owning your sexuality with deeper authenticity the question will become less about CAN i be a gay man and a Christian and more about HOW do i be a gay man and a Christian.
i am personally very stunned that you had the courage to post the link to this blog where i found it. i greatly respect your honesty and i come to your thoughts not with pity or rejection, but a genuine interest in what you have to show me about learning to trust my own discernment while still honoring Christ and His body.
Thank you for this gift of transparency its one of the rare treasures I have collected and it comes to me at a time where it is very much needed in terms of things I am facing in my own life.
I wish you peace and intimacy with Christ.
You are a brother in the Lord and I will never see you as anything less.
Greetings, David. Steve F. from “a site we have in common.” Obviously, I found you here from your blog link on your profile there.
I’m just getting started reading your blog, but so far, your story sounds so familiar to my own – except for the 30 years of self-denial and self-loathing I spent to finally “hit bottom” (pardon the pun). Most of those 30 years were spent either in a str8 marriage (6 years) or waiting for God to fix me (13 of the last sixteen).
I decided three years ago that there was nothing to fix, so here I am, a fellow side-A gay Christian, at 50.
Your story is particularly poignant because I just came back from the wedding of a dear friend who was my last attempt at str8 life. I even invited her to visit me in Chicago at seminary for a big dinner-dance. It was fun, but it was clearly “just friends,” which sucked because she really, really wanted to upgrade from Friends 2004 to Wife 2.0.
So I had to deal with the death of my seminary dreams (finances killed that one), the death of my ministry plans, and the final death of my hetero life, all in the same 2 years. I was a load of laughs to be around, as you might imagine.
Life is changing slowly – in large part because of GCN. I’m glad to have found you – come over and check my site out, when you get bored…
I’d also be curious about the site you linked to that led Jennifer here…